You read the gospels and you don’t find a Jesus full of nuance. You find a Jesus who lambasts his opponents fiercely (Matthew 23, Mark 11), who says deeply offensive things to people to provoke and to teach (Luke 14, Matthew 15), and who doesn’t ever fudge his answers.
Except, you read the gospels and you do find a Jesus full of nuance. You find a Jesus who takes the Old Testament law and widens or narrows it, showing how it is to be read carefully (Matthew 5), who redirects questions he rejects the framing of (Mark 12, Luke 10), and who makes finely grained arguments (John 7, Luke 20).
My framing isn’t particularly enlightening, but we sometimes meet people who argue that Jesus was nuanced and so we should be too. I certainly agree that Jesus is our model not just for what we think but how we think and argue as well. Except, often what the person means is that Jesus was in some fashion ‘fuzzy.’ He widened and softened the Law, perhaps even disagreeing with it, and therefore we too should not be too dogmatic about things the Bible says.
None of that is true, but it’s a common argument. I’ve heard people make this sort of argument and then suggest that we shouldn’t be too dogmatic about the things Jesus said either, which is a strange direction to think in. Almost always it requires us to forget that Jesus spoke clearly, in the gospels, about hell (Matthew 13), sexual immortality (Matthew 5; 15), divorce (Matthew 5; 19), pornography (Matthew 5), and many more hot button topics people would prefer we stopped talking about. The ‘Jesus was nuanced so we should nuance away dogma’ definitely requires us to forget that our evangelical commitments need us to claim that the Old Testament and rest of the New Testament are Jesus’ words too.
What I’m interested in though, is that Jesus was nuanced. He was clear in what he taught (‘black-and-white’ even!) but he was nuanced. In general discussion in churches people often assume that clarity and nuance are different things. I disagree. In this way of talking ‘nuance’ means softening things until we aren’t saying something that might be offensive or provocative or challenging. That is nothing like Jesus, and if we need more arguments than that (we shouldn’t), the young who are flooding into our churches aren’t interested in fluff, they want hot-blooded, red-meat religion where we tell them the truth straight down the line. Nuancing ourselves to death on the altar of kindness or being ‘missional’ ends up with our blood everywhere without any discernible benefit.
But Jesus was nuanced in the sense he was careful, precise, and would do the ‘you have heard it said, but I say to you’ raising of the bar when quoting scripture. Jesus didn’t teach with a blunderbuss, which was a precursor to the modern shotgun filled with lead balls, metal scraps, nails and anything else you could scrap together. With a blunderbuss, everything in front of you gets mangled. Jesus taught with a rifle, carefully aimed, but still hitting his targets with powerful effect.
We should aim to do the same thing. When we teach, we must be clear, not shying away from difficult things to say, especially those that we fear are most unpopular in our particular church context. We should also be nuanced, we can use overstatement for rhetorical effect but with clarity about what we’re doing, but we should finely slice theological categories with precision. We should teach the Bible well and clearly. We shouldn’t fall back into narrow soundbites but express a range of thought.
People won’t hear that right. They will hear clarity as a lack of nuance, they will hear the first thing we say and not the third that qualifies it, and they won’t want careful arguments that sometimes put us on one side or another of a contemporary debate and sometimes diagonalize them in a third way.
Let them.
I don’t mean that being properly heard isn’t important, it is, but I do think we can allow that to crowd out saying the true thing or carefully nuancing the thing that needs to be nuanced. We should absolutely work on our communication to find ways to thread the needle, but we shouldn’t be afraid of saying things that need to be said.
This goes not just for our public ministry but also for the way we do theology. I think my writing is pretty nuanced, often trying to thread between a Scylla and Charybdis to say something others haven’t said as far as I’m aware. You will have to judge my success with that. It only comes across as nuanced if you’re familiar with the things I’m threading between, I suspect. That’s fine, the ideas are more important than what perception people build of me as I write. My point is simply that what some would consider nuanced others would consider dogmatic and entrenched.
That’s not a fight you can win, so it’s not particularly worth trying to. Follow Jesus in careful application of the scriptures. Follow Jesus in direct clarity about the truth of the world.
We need more careful, finely grained theology in our churches. We need clear declaration of the truths of the Bible, in and out of season. I think you can do both things at the same time. Or, at least, it’s a needle worth trying to thread.
Photo by Bud Silva on Unsplash
To subscribe and receive email notifications for future posts, scroll all the way to the bottom of the page.
Would you like to support my work? The best thing you can do is share this post with your friends. Why not consider also joining my Patreon to keep my writing free for everyone. You can see other ways to support me here.